Celestia Forums

I thought this should rotate, but...


The goal here is to have a reference frame where I face away from the sun and can show the changing constellations through the year.

roland

There's a problem with that frame. The RelativePosition and RelativeVelocity vectors are defined by a target and observer object. If you omit the observer, it defaults to the coordinate frame center, which is Earth both the body frame and orbit frame. The problem is that Earth is also the target object for all but of the vectors. You can't define a frame with zero length vectors. I think that what you probably meant was to make Sol the target object in each case. That will work and give you the rotating reference frame that you want--if you make the observer 'sync orbit' by pressing y, the observer should rotate in the way that you expect.

(The name 'sync orbit' is a leftover from the early days of Celestia. What it actually does is to put the observer in the body-fixed frame of the selected object.)

--Chris

First, thank you for a very lucid explanation of what was wrong with my frame. It helped me to better understand frame definitions in general.

I replaced Sol/Earth with Sol in each case, and further adjusted to make the z-axis "up" wrt to the ecliptic. When I "goto" this location, then do a "sync orbit" I don't quite get what I was expecting. Perhaps I misunderstood. If I center then Sun, then do a sync orbit, I get something that appears correct until I then do a center on Earth and discover I managed to end up on the opposite side of the Sun from it!

Both the old, badly defined frame, and the good frame work if I center the sun the lock on it.

So, while I understand what made my old frame a badly defined one, I'm still not sure I understand how to get a frame which will intrinsically behave the way I was thinking. Here's my last attempt:

roland